Comparison between canals and drains
Following are the points of comparison between canal and drains.
Drain | Canal | |
Nature | Drain is naturally made. | It is an artificial made structure. |
Alignment | Its alignment varies with the passage of time. | Mostly it keeps its alignment. |
Approach | Meandering and braided in most cases. | Canals are almost straight except on designed curves. |
Bed slope | Bed slope varies section to section and is normally 0.01% to 0.05%. | Designed on a specific bed slope for a reach. Bed slope varies from 1/10,000 to 1/20,000. |
Construction cost | Normally no construction cost but training works involve a huge sum of money. | High construction cost but low maintenance cost. |
Discharge | Higher discharge than that of canal. | Lower than drain. |
Free board | No proper free boards so water over flowing from banks during floods. | A certain free board is provided to keep the water within it. Usually free board > 2′. |
Losses | Mostly there are seepage and evaporational losses. | Evaporational losses are low but there are seepage losses in unlined canals. |
Side slopes | No definite side slopes. | Side slope is 1:1 to 2:1 in cutting and upto 3:1 in filling. |
Supply of water | Drains supply water to the barrages. | Canals supply water to the branch canals and to distributories/minor canals. |
Source of water | Glaciers, springs, rains, catchment areas are the source of water to the drains. | Canals get water from a barrage. |
Level of water | The level of water in the drain is called high flood level. | The level of water in canal is called full supply level. |
Leave a Reply